The Dangers of the “Woke, White Leftist” as Seen in Native Son
In Native Son we are presented with a seemingly new, dangerous form of white person; The “woke” leftist, as seen in the character of Mary Dalton. Mary identifies herself as a communist, cares about social issues, and is interested in improving the lives of black Americans, but fails to include one important thing in her activism; understanding of those who she is trying to help. This shortcoming in her activism is something that many white activists lack, and Native Son warns us of how dangerous this can be. We see each of Mary’s attempts at activism in her interactions with Bigger, as well as how they end up endangering or worsening things for him.
Mary first meets Bigger in the middle of his job interview with Mr. Dalton, immediately asking him if he belongs to a union, something that was very frowned upon by possible employers back then and could have cost him his job, which Bigger acknowledges, saying “She's making me lose my job! He thought. Goddamn! He knew nothing about unions, except that they were considered bad. And what did she mean by talking to him this way in front of Mr. Dalton, who, surely, didn’t like unions?” (Wright 52). In her pursuit towards bettering working conditions for people like Bigger, Mary fails to recognize the danger that she is putting him in. She is jeopardizing his chance at a job, which could have negative economic repercussions for Bigger and his family. In this scene, the livelihood of Bigger and his family comes at the expense of Mary’s “activism.”
For Mary, being a communist and being perceived as such is not a big deal. Being a communist is just Mary’s rebellion from society as a “woke” individual, but to Bigger, a black man, this label means much more. Mary is a white woman that comes from affluent backgrounds. Communism can be a phase for her, she can move past this stage in her life and continue to prosper. Because of her background, Mary would never have to deal with the economic and social repercussions of being a communist, as her identity as a rich, white woman comes first. However this is different for Bigger, since being labeled as a communist would have major consequences. If associated with communism, Bigger likely wouldn't be able to make enough money to survive, would be subject to widespread hate, and a victim to extreme violence and racism, an experience very common for communists of color at the time. Mary is completely oblivious to the experience of the black communist, and therefore has no understanding of why the label that she wants to place on Bigger may be dangerous. Mary’s activism is self-serving and only builds up her ego, all while possibly destroying Bigger's future. Mary’s selfish pursuit of “wokeness” puts Bigger in danger. Her leftist and communist viewpoint, though not initially negative, is dangerous as soon as it becomes her whole identity. This distinguishing characteristic of many white leftists that Mary exhibits is what Native Son warns us of.
White people are becoming more educated on issues of racism, inequality, and sexism, which is ultimately a good thing. But this newfound social awareness can pose a danger to people of color, especially black people. Being educated on the injustices of society is a positive thing. It is okay to be white and “woke,” but the “wokeness” of the white person becomes dangerous when it becomes their whole identity, and now, in their minds, outweighs the racial privilege that they hold. The activism of the white person turns sour when it becomes self-serving, posing a great danger to black Americans. The “woke,” white leftist is not a thing of the past, or a fictional character like Mary Dalton, but an immediate danger that Richard Wright's Native Son warns us of.
Wow, you really put the what the Daltons represent and who they are in today's society perfectly! I agree that being educated and wanting to help is good, but when it becomes merely another way to build up your ego or soothe your guilt.... A great example like you mentioned is Mary, and especially how she treats Bigger and why she's interested in him. He's more like a zoo animal to satisfy her own curiosity than a human; certainly; she's not any less bigoted than the violently racist policemen -- just in a different way.
ReplyDeleteHi Andrea, I think you really hit some of the main ideas of the dangers of white wokeness really well in this blog post. One idea I was grappling with that you put really well into words was the fact that for Mary, being a communist is mostly an act of rebellion - it's not something that's really going to be dangerous for her or put barriers up for her in society but for Bigger, it would have much bigger consequences. I also was fascinated by your idea of Mary being oblivious to the harm that comes with being a black communist. Great job!
ReplyDeleteThis blog post brought up some really insightful points Andrea! I think you pin pointed the issue with Mary's "activism" very well; it's not her interest in social justice that's problematic, it's Mary's motive behind her interest. Rather than truly trying to understand systemic racism and classism, Mary treats her "wokeness" as a rebellion, or a fun thing she can do to feel good about herself. I also appreciate your inclusion of Mary's class privilege. Not only is Mary white, she's also rich, which protects her from the consequences of having controversial views. Great post!
ReplyDeleteThis is a really incredible blog post Andrea! You did a wonderful job at encapsulating what makes Mary so problematic in this book. I enjoyed how you noted that for Mary, "Communism can be a phase for her, she can move past this stage in her life and continue to prosper." This highlights the dilemma of how a person of color's identity cannot be seen as separate from their political or religious beliefs. For Bigger, his political beliefs and racial identity are intersectional and intertwined, but Mary has the luxury and privilege of being able to separate the two.
ReplyDeleteI loved the ideas that you brought up in this blog post Andrea. You did a wonderful articulating the harmful mindsets and actions of "woke ,white liberals". I agreed about the point you brought up that although Mary believed she was being "inclusive" or "helpful" to the black community solely through her communist title, in reality she was only using it as a way to rebel against her own parents or "society". She didn't realize that it didn't matter how much she identified with being "woke" or a "communist", it wouldn't take away from her whiteness and she failed to see how that affected Bigger. Great post!
ReplyDeleteThis was super well written and I like how you clearly and concisely explained your points and ideas. I completely agree with what you've written, I actually wrote my essay on this exact topic and linked it back to being the reason why Mary was killed. I really like how in the last paragraph you pick apart how while yes, it is important to be educated on such topics, it becomes a danger when it becomes your whole personality. Again, really great post!
ReplyDeleteThis is a wonderful blog post with some incredibly thoughtful points! I really like that you delve into the meaning of why Mary is so "woke" and is a communist. She is not an activist out of the feeling to help right the wrongs in society, rather, she is trying to rebel by being "woke". I also really like how you point out that her identity as a rich, white woman would come first in the way she is viewed by society, therefore not having to suffer the same repercussions as someone else. One other point I really liked is the danger of a white persons' entire identity revolving their "wokeness". This is such an insightful post, great job!
ReplyDelete